Birthday Party Supplies

Celebrate in style with our diverse range of Birthday Party Supplies! Whether you're planning a princess parade, a superhero showdown, a roaring dinosaur adventure, or a chic adult gathering, we have the decorations, tableware, and accessories to bring your vision to life. Explore our themed selections or mix and match to create a truly unique party atmosphere. Don't forget to browse our fantastic candle collection to complete the cake!

Adult BirthdayAdult Birthday
Teen BirthdayTeen Birthday
Kid's BirthdayKid's Birthday
Boy's BirthdayBoy's Birthday
Girl's BirthdayGirl's Birthday
Birthday Party Supplies By AgeBirthday Party Supplies By Age
Sidebar

Categories
Filter
  • 10
  • 15
  • 20
  • 25
  • 30
  • 50
  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
Sort

Sort by:

  • Featured
  • Most relevant
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old
  • Happy Birthday balloon lunch napkins 16ct colorful disposable party napkins Manahawkin NJ

      Happy Birthday Balloon Lunch Napkins – 16 Count Colorful Disposable Party Napkins

      Upgrade your party table instantly—these Happy Birthday lunch napkins bring bold color, convenience, and festive style to every celebration. Perfect for meals, desserts, and everything in between, they’re a must-have for keeping your setup clean while looking party-ready. Featuring fun balloon-style lettering that spells...
      $2.99
      $3.49
      $2.99
    • Happy Birthday balloon 7 inch dessert plates 8ct colorful party plates Manahawkin NJ

        Happy Birthday Balloon 7” Dessert Plates – 8 Count Colorful Party Plates

        Complete your party table the right way—these Happy Birthday dessert plates bring color, convenience, and a polished look to any celebration. Don’t settle for plain tableware when you can serve cake and treats in style. Featuring playful balloon-style “Happy Birthday” lettering in bright multicolor...
        $2.99
        $4.69
        $2.99
      • Happy Birthday balloon plastic table cover 54x84 rectangular party tablecloth Manahawkin NJHappy Birthday plastic table cover in retail packaging rectangular 54x84

          Happy Birthday Balloon Plastic Table Cover – 54” x 84” Rectangular Party Tablecloth

          Set the foundation for a standout party—this Happy Birthday table cover instantly transforms any table into a festive centerpiece while protecting it from spills, messes, and cleanup stress. Featuring a bright white background with multicolor “Happy Birthday” balloon-style lettering and scattered confetti, this rectangular...
          $7.99
          $7.99
        • Packaged rose gold 32 inch hanging swirl decorations 3ct available in Manahawkin, NJ party supply store

            Rose Gold Happy Birthday Hanging Swirl Decorations 32" – 3 Count Foil Party Decor

            Transform your party space in minutes with these Rose Gold “Happy Birthday” Hanging Swirl Decorations—an effortless way to add height, shimmer, and celebration-ready style to any birthday setup. With eye-catching foil swirls and elegant lettering, these decorations instantly elevate your décor. Don’t wait until...
            $3.99
            $5.49
            $3.99
          • Packaged rose gold birthday badge pin 1 count available in Manahawkin, NJ party supply storeClose-up of glitz rose gold birthday badge with it’s my birthday text

              Rose Gold “It’s My Birthday” Badge Pin – Glitz Party Accessory (1 Count)

              Make the guest of honor stand out in style with this Rose Gold “It’s My Birthday” Badge Pin—the perfect statement piece to celebrate their special day. With its eye-catching glitz design and elegant rose gold finish, this badge instantly adds a fun, festive touch...
              $3.49
              $4.99
              $3.49
            • Showing the table cover rose gold birthday party kit with tableware and decorations available in Manahawkin NJRose gold balloon on a white background
              Out Of Stock

              Rose Gold Happy Birthday Party Kit – Tableware & Decorations Set for 8 Guests

              Create a stunning, fully coordinated birthday celebration in minutes with this Rose Gold Happy Birthday Party Kit—your all-in-one solution for effortless style and convenience. Designed to take the stress out of party planning, this bundle includes everything you need to set the table and...
              $29.99
              $34.99
              $29.99
              Out Of Stock
            • Silver happy birthday foil hanging swirl decorations 32 inch 3 count ceiling party decor Manahawkin NJClose up of "Happy Birthday" 32 inch silver hanging swirl decorations

                Silver 32" Happy Birthday Foil Hanging Swirl Decorations (3ct) – Shimmering Ceiling Party Décor

                Add instant shine and movement to your party—before these decorations sell out. Create a festive, eye-catching atmosphere with these Silver “Happy Birthday” Foil Hanging Swirl Decorations. Designed to shimmer and spin with every movement, these 32-inch swirls bring energy and elegance to any birthday...
                $3.99
                $4.79
                $3.99
              • Packaged black and silver it's my birthday celebration pin retail packaging available at Party Fair in Manahawkin NJBlack and silver it's my birthday button glitz celebration pin party accessory

                  Black & Silver “It’s My Birthday” Button – Glitz Celebration Pin for All Ages

                  Make sure everyone knows—it’s your day. Grab yours before they’re gone. Celebrate in style with this Black & Silver “It’s My Birthday” Glitz Button, the perfect way to stand out and let everyone know who the guest of honor is. Featuring a bold black...
                  $3.49
                  $4.99
                  $3.49
                • Black & Silver Glitz Birthday Party Kit – Plates, Napkins, Table Cover, Decorations, Candles, Balloons & Celebration PinBlack & Silver Glitz Birthday Party Kit – Plates, Napkins, Table Cover, Decorations, Candles, Balloons & Celebration Pin
                  Out Of Stock

                  Black & Silver Glitz Birthday Party Kit – Plates, Napkins, Table Cover, Decorations, Candles, Balloons & Celebration Pin

                  Everything you need for a standout birthday celebration—grab this all-in-one kit before it sells out. Take the stress out of party planning with this Black & Silver Glitz Birthday Party Kit, designed to give your party a coordinated, stylish look. From tableware and décor...
                  $29.99
                  $34.99
                  $29.99
                  Out Of Stock
                • Mini metallic gold number 3 birthday candle cake topper in Manahawkin, NJ

                    Mini Metallic Gold Number 3 Birthday Pick Candle – 3" Cake Topper

                    Add a touch of shine to your celebration with this elegant Mini Metallic Gold Number 3 Candle. Designed with a sleek metallic finish, this candle brings a polished, festive look to cakes, cupcakes, and dessert tables. Perfect for third birthdays, anniversaries, New Year celebrations,...
                    $1.99
                    $2.49
                    $1.99
                  • Mini metallic gold number 4 birthday candle cake topper in Manahawkin, NJ

                      Mini Metallic Gold Number 4 Birthday Pick Candle – 3" Cake Topper

                      Turn any cake into a celebration centerpiece with this Mini Metallic Gold Number 4 Candle. Its sleek, reflective gold finish adds instant elegance, making your dessert look professionally styled with minimal effort. Perfect for everything from a child’s 4th birthday to milestone celebrations like...
                      $1.99
                      $2.49
                      $1.99
                    • Mini metallic gold number 5 birthday candle cake topper in Manahawkin, NJ

                        Mini Metallic Gold Number 5 Birthday Pick Candle – 3" Cake Topper

                        Add a touch of shine and sophistication to your celebration with this Mini Metallic Gold Number 5 Candle. Its sleek gold finish instantly enhances any cake, turning even a simple dessert into a standout centerpiece. Whether you're celebrating a 5th birthday or a milestone...
                        $1.99
                        $2.49
                        $1.99
                      • Mini metallic gold number 6 birthday candle cake topper in Manahawkin, NJ

                          Mini Metallic Gold Number 6 Birthday Pick Candle – 3" Cake Topper

                          Bring a polished, celebratory touch to your cake with this Mini Metallic Gold Number 6 Candle. Its sleek, reflective finish adds instant elegance, making any dessert look party-ready in seconds. Perfect for everything from a 6th birthday to milestone celebrations like 16, 26, or...
                          $1.99
                          $2.49
                          $1.99
                        • Mini metallic gold number 7 birthday candle cake topper in Manahawkin, NJ

                            Mini Metallic Gold Number 7 Birthday Pick Candle – 3" Cake Topper

                            Add a sleek, celebratory touch to your cake with this Mini Metallic Gold Number 7 Candle. Its radiant gold finish instantly elevates your dessert, turning any cake into a stylish centerpiece in seconds. Whether you're celebrating a 7th birthday or a milestone like 17,...
                            $1.99
                            $2.49
                            $1.99
                          • Mini metallic gold number 8 birthday candle cake topper in Manahawkin, NJ

                              Mini Metallic Gold Number 8 Birthday Pick Candle – 3" Cake Topper

                              Give your cake a polished, celebratory look with this Mini Metallic Gold Number 8 Candle. Its sleek gold finish instantly adds sophistication, transforming any cake into a stylish centerpiece in seconds. Perfect for a 8th birthday or milestone events like 18, 28, 38, or...
                              $1.99
                              $2.49
                              $1.99
                            • Mini Metallic Gold Number 9 Birthday Pick Candle – 3" Cake Topper

                                Mini Metallic Gold Number 9 Birthday Pick Candle – 3" Cake Topper

                                Complete your cake with a sleek, eye-catching finish using this Mini Metallic Gold Number 9 Candle. Its radiant gold shine adds instant elegance, making any dessert feel celebration-ready in seconds. Perfect for a 9th birthday or milestone moments like 19, 29, 39, or 90,...
                                $1.99
                                $2.49
                                $1.99
                              • 3D shark pinata with realistic design displayed for party decoration in Manahawkin, NJ at Party Fair

                                  3D Shark Pinata – Large Shaped Party Decoration

                                  Make a splash at your next celebration with this bold and exciting 3D shark-shaped pinata—a show-stopping centerpiece that instantly turns any party into an unforgettable event. With its dynamic three-dimensional design, this shark pinata brings high-energy fun and visual impact that guests can’t ignore....
                                  $24.99
                                  $29.99
                                  $24.99
                                • Hello Kitty and Friends 3D piñata party game from Party Fair in Manahawkin NJ

                                    Hello Kitty and Friends 3D Piñata – Large Party Game Decoration

                                    Make your celebration instantly adorable and unforgettable with the Hello Kitty and Friends 3D Piñata—a fun-filled party game and charming centerpiece all in one. This large, colorful piñata brings excitement to any gathering as guests take turns trying to release the hidden surprises inside....
                                    $39.99
                                    $39.99
                                  • Paw Patrol napkins showing colorful character design 16ct party napkins available at Party Fair in Manahawkin NJ

                                      Paw Patrol Luncheon Napkins – 16 Count Disposable Party Pack

                                      Keep your party clean, coordinated, and full of character with these Paw Patrol Luncheon Napkins. Designed to bring fun and function together, this 16-count pack is the perfect addition to any themed birthday setup. Featuring colorful Paw Patrol graphics kids instantly recognize, these disposable...
                                      $4.59
                                      $5.09
                                      $4.59
                                    • Sweet Sixteen Blush Luncheon Napkins Manahawkin, NJ Party Fair pink party napkins

                                        Sweet Sixteen Blush Luncheon Napkins – 16 Count Disposable Paper Napkins

                                        Celebrate in style with these Sweet Sixteen Blush Luncheon Napkins Package of 16, designed to bring a soft, elegant touch to any milestone event. Perfect for Sweet 16 celebrations, home parties, and banquet-style gatherings, these blush pink paper napkins help create a coordinated and...
                                        $6.99
                                        $8.10
                                        $6.99
                                      • Blush Birthday Hot Stamped Beverage Napkin Manahawkin, NJ Party Fair elegant birthday party supplies

                                          Blush Happy Birthday Gold Hot Stamped Beverage Napkins 16ct

                                          Celebrate in style with these elegant Blush Happy Birthday Gold Hot Stamped Beverage Napkins. Featuring a beautiful scripted gold foil “Happy Birthday” caption on a soft blush background, these disposable party napkins instantly elevate birthday tables, dessert stations, drink carts, and celebration setups. Perfect...
                                          $5.99
                                          $6.80
                                          $5.99
                                        • Black Happy Birthday Letter Banner Manahawkin, NJ Party Fair birthday party decoration

                                            Black Happy Birthday Letter Banner 6"H x 7.75 ft

                                            Make any birthday celebration bold and unforgettable with this Black Happy Birthday Letter Banner. Measuring 6 inches high by 7.75 feet long, this classic party banner delivers a strong visual statement that instantly elevates your birthday décor. Perfect for kids’ birthdays, gaming-themed parties, milestone...
                                            $4.99
                                            $5.30
                                            $4.99
                                          • Birthday Plates 8ct in Manahawkin, NJ at Party Fair, showing colorful balloon-shaped 8.25-inch paper plates with a Happy Birthday caption

                                              Birthday Plates 8ct – Balloon Shaped 8.25" Paper Plates

                                              Make the birthday table extra festive with fun balloon-shaped plates! These 8.25-inch paper plates feature a cheerful “Happy Birthday” caption and a colorful design that brings instant party spirit to celebrations for boys, girls, and all ages. Perfect for birthday parties, snacks, desserts, light...
                                              $4.99
                                              $4.99

                                            Recently Viewed Products